Score: 10

"I like this more than the Black Mages' take on it"

submission: Dancing Mad: Esperoid - Part 1

date: October 20, 2009

Yeah, that's right, I think it's better than what Uematsu's own band played. Great job, man.

Score: 1

"horribly off key"

submission: Wolf3D(TDJ Rmx)

date: October 19, 2009

This is just a mess of instruments playing the wrong notes. Terrible.

Score: 10

"Captures the mood perfectly"

submission: Wolfenstein 3D Menu Music

date: August 25, 2009

Your rendition of Wondering About My Loved Ones is my favorite so far. I like the original bits you added. The whole thing is very sad and relaxing.

The strings at the end should probably have their volume reduced a bit. The accordion bits are sadly missing, but IMO that just accentuates the main melody of the song, giving it more of that sad, longing mood, and admittedly, the strings are only there for a few seconds at the end, so I won't count that against you. Good job.

Score: 10

"HOLY SHIT"

submission: MarioRPG: Halloween for Smithy

date: November 2, 2008

If you had never told me it was started two days ago I never would have known. It's amazing. Absolutely perfect.

Score: 8

"Not bad!"

submission: Bracksta Dark Overflow (vol 2)

date: October 26, 2008

I thought the tune was pretty good! It could use improvement still but I'm not quite sure what it's missing.

Score: 8

"Good foundation, but it needs to be expanded."

submission: Imperial march metal

date: October 18, 2008

I'll agree with the others that the song does need to go further. Hearing this, I do have hope that a full rendition of the metal imperial march would kick ass, but right now all we have is 16 seconds. :/

Score: 10

"W O W"

submission: Sonic 2 Chemical Plant Metal

date: October 18, 2008

I usually don't like remakes of old video game songs on NG because half of them are lazy. This one really does the old song justice and then some! Great freaking job. I wish all remakes had this kind of quality.

Score: 8

"Excellent remake."

submission: Duke Nukem - Stalker

date: July 18, 2008

From Duke 3D I believe. Level 1 of Ep 1. I think I prefer it to the original.

Score: 7

"Pretty good Tune!"

submission: Sonic 3 - BossBattle METALIZED

date: July 12, 2008

It's a good remake. The music is all there, but you lose 2 points for the volume being so loud that it causes distortion. It's otherwise a fantastic remake.

Score: 9

"Fantastic!"

submission: C&C - Act on instinct

date: July 12, 2008

BUT U NEED 2 TERN THA BASS UP!

It's a great song but the Bass guitar is the center stage in this song. It's way too quiet in this remix.